MyGreek
Payments & refunds

Returned bank payments and disputes

What happens when a member's bank sends back a bank payment (an ACH return) or a member disputes a card payment, what it costs your chapter, and what to do.

Sometimes money a member paid gets taken back after the payment looked done. For a bank payment that's an ACH return. For a card payment it's a dispute (also called a chargeback). This page explains what each one changes and what chapter admins should do.

What an ACH return is

An ACH return is when the member's bank sends back a bank (ACH) payment. Common reasons are not enough money in the account, a closed or wrong account, or the account holder telling their bank they didn't approve the payment. The reason shows on the payment as its Decline Reason.

A bank payment can show Succeeded and still be returned later. Most returns come within a few business days. Some, such as an account holder saying they didn't approve the payment, can come weeks later.

What changes when a bank payment is returned

  • The payment changes to Failed on Payments, with the bank's reason.
  • The member owes the amount again. It's added back to the charges the payment covered. If those charges are past due and your chapter has late fees turned on, a late fee can be added.
  • A payment plan is canceled. If the returned payment was a payment plan installment, the installment is marked Failed and the plan is canceled. Returned bank payments aren't retried.
  • Your payout is lower. The returned amount comes out of a payout, with an ACH return fee. In the payout breakdown it shows under ACH returns & disputes as "[charge type] · ACH return", and the fee under Fees as ACH return fees. A returned convenience fee shows as Convenience fees returned. See See what's in a payout. The fee amount is listed at mygreek.us/fees.

Who is notified about a returned payment

  • The member (and the parent or other payer, if they made the payment) gets an email, Payment Returned - Action Required. It says the payment was marked as declined and asks them to log in and pay again or contact their treasurer.
  • Chapter admins get an email, ACH Payment Returned - [member name], with the payment, charges, amount and reason, plus a push notification in the mobile app. Each admin can turn these off with ACH Returns under Settings → Admin Notifications.

The same notices go out when a bank payment fails before it ever succeeds.

What to do about a returned payment

  1. Open Payments, find the payment (it now shows Failed) and check its Decline Reason.
  2. Contact the member. They need to pay again, with another bank account or a card if the reason was a closed or invalid account.
  3. If it was a payment plan installment, the plan was canceled. The member can propose a new plan, or you can offer one. See How payment plans work.
  4. If a late fee was added because of the return and you want to waive it, reverse it. See Reverse (waive) a late fee.

You can't retry a returned payment from MyGreek. The member has to make a new payment.

What a card dispute is

A dispute is when a cardholder asks their card company to reverse a card payment, for example because they don't recognize it or say they were charged by mistake.

When a member disputes a payment:

  • The disputed amount comes out of a payout, with a chargeback fee. In the payout breakdown it shows under ACH returns & disputes as "[charge type] · disputed", and the fee under Fees as Chargeback fees. The fee amount is listed at mygreek.us/fees.
  • If the dispute is decided in your chapter's favor, the money is added back to a later payout as "[charge type] · dispute won back". A convenience fee given back shows as Convenience fees won back.

Chapter admins get an email and an app notification when a member disputes a card payment, and again when the dispute is decided. While it's open, the payment shows Failed and the amount is back on the member's balance. If your chapter wins, the payment shows Succeeded again and the amount comes off the balance.

What changes while a dispute is open

  • The payment shows Failed on Payments, with the reason Card payment disputed.
  • The member owes the amount again. It gets the usual payment reminders, and a late fee if your chapter has late fees turned on and the charge is past due.
  • If only part of the payment is disputed, or the payment was already refunded, MyGreek doesn't change the payment or the balance. The dispute email says so.

When a dispute is decided

  • If your chapter wins, the payment shows Succeeded again and the amount comes off the member's balance. A late fee added while the dispute was open stays until you reverse it (see Reverse (waive) a late fee). If the member paid again in the meantime, the extra becomes account credit and goes toward their other open charges. The email says how much.
  • If your chapter loses, the payment stays Failed, with the reason Card payment disputed (dispute lost), and the member still owes the amount.

Each admin gets these emails, Card Payment Disputed - [member name], Dispute Won - [member name] and Dispute Lost - [member name], unless they turn off Card Disputes under Settings → Admin Notifications. Members and payers don't get an email about a dispute.

What to do about a dispute

You don't need to do anything when you get a dispute email. MyGreek responds to the dispute and will reach out to you if we need more information or proof.

Common questions

Why did our payout come out negative?

When returns, disputes and refunds add up to more than members paid in that payout, the difference is withdrawn from your chapter's bank account. See How payouts work.

The member says they had money in the account. What now?

The reason comes from their bank. Ask them to check with their bank, then pay again. If they pay from the same account, it can be returned again.

Is this the same as a payout being returned?

No. A returned payout is when your chapter's bank sends back money MyGreek sent you. See A payout was returned by your bank.

On this page